Skip to content

Free tool

Insurance agency marketing budget calculator

Published November 16, 2026 · Updated November 18, 2026 · Medicare Advantage figures: CMS, plan year 2027

Work an insurance marketing budget backwards from the sales you want. Leads needed = policies ÷ (contact rate × close rate). Media budget = leads × cost per lead. Cost per sale = total monthly cost ÷ policies. If cost per sale stays under first-year commission, the spend pays for itself. The calculator runs this with your numbers.

Your numbers

Every field starts empty on purpose: use your own numbers from your CRM, dialer and commission statements. Results update as you type.

1 · What you want to sell

What you actually receive in the first year per sale, from your own contract or statements.

Work it out from premium and your commission rate

2 · Your lead channel
Running your own ads? Work out cost per lead

Share of leads you actually speak to.

Share of the leads you spoke to who bought.

3 · Fixed monthly cost (optional)

Comparing a managed program? Our published tiers, from our pricing page:

4 · Compare a second lead source (optional)
Second lead source

Source A is the lead channel in step 2 with the fixed cost in step 3. Enter source B below: the same policies and commission, bought or generated a different way (shared vs exclusive leads, bought leads vs your own ads, one vendor vs another).

Everything you'd pay each month if you ran B instead: include the CRM or dialer cost again if both sources need it, plus any management fee B brings with it. Empty counts as $0.

5 · Value past year one (optional)
Renewal commission and retention

The main result judges the month on first-year commission. Add what a policy pays at each renewal and how many of your policies stay on the books, and the calculator also shows what this month's sales are worth over the years you choose. Use your own numbers: your commission schedule and your book's history.

What one policy still in force pays you in a renewal year. For premium-based lines, your renewal rate × the renewal premium.

Your retention: of the policies alive at the start of a year, the share that renew.

Fill in policies, commission, cost per lead, contact rate and close rate to see the leads you need, your budget and your cost per sale.

Lead vendor scorecard: last month's results

The planner above works forward from rates. This scorecard works back from what already happened: for each lead source, enter what you spent, how many leads came in, how many you spoke to and how many policies you sold. It scores up to three sources side by side and shows the lead price each one would need to match the best.

Printed on the scorecard. A full month or more of results per source reads better than a week.

The same number as in the planner. Adds commission earned, what was left and the break-even lead price.

Source 1

Everything paid for this source: leads, fees, its own software.

Splits a reach problem from a selling problem.

Issued, net of chargebacks if you know them.

Source 2

Everything paid for this source: leads, fees, its own software.

Splits a reach problem from a selling problem.

Issued, net of chargebacks if you know them.

Source 3

Everything paid for this source: leads, fees, its own software.

Splits a reach problem from a selling problem.

Issued, net of chargebacks if you know them.

Fill in spend, leads and policies sold for at least one source to score it. Add a second and third source to compare them.

How the calculator works out your budget

The calculator uses five numbers you already have: the policies you want to write, what each one pays you in the first year, what a lead costs, how many leads you reach, and how many of those you close. It adds nothing of its own. Here is every formula it runs, in order:

ResultFormula
Sales per leadcontact rate × close rate
Leads neededpolicies wanted ÷ sales per lead, rounded up
Media budgetleads needed × cost per lead
Total monthly costmedia budget + fixed monthly cost
Cost per saletotal monthly cost ÷ policies
First-year commissionpolicies × commission per policy
Break-even close rate(policies × cost per lead) ÷ (contact rate × (first-year commission − fixed cost))
Most you can pay per lead(first-year commission − fixed cost) × sales per lead ÷ policies

Contact rate and close rate are kept apart on purpose. A blended "close rate on all leads" can't tell you whether a bad month was a reach problem (leads you never spoke to) or a selling problem (conversations that didn't close), and the two have different fixes. Contact rate is the share of leads you actually speak to; close rate is the share of those conversations that end in a sale.

If you run your own ads rather than buying leads, open "Running your own ads?" under cost per lead: cost per click divided by your landing page's conversion rate gives the cost per lead to use. For what clicks run in each line, seeinsurance cost per click by line of business.

Worked example: a Medicare agent's AEP month

Take a Medicare agent in a state paid at the national rate who wants 20 Medicare Advantage enrollments in an Annual Enrollment Period month, and expects half of them to be clients switching from another MA plan. The commission comes from CMS's published maximum for plan year 2027. The lead price, contact rate and close rate are placeholders picked to keep the arithmetic easy to follow, not market averages: put your own in. The "Load the worked example" button at the top of the calculator fills these inputs in.

InputValueWhere it comes from
Enrollments wanted this month20The agent's goal
Commission per enrollment$54450% at $725 (initial) + 50% at $363 (renewal), CMS maximums
Cost per lead$40Placeholder
Contact rate50%Placeholder
Close rate25%Placeholder
Fixed monthly cost$0None in this example

What the calculator returns:

  1. Sales per lead: 50% × 25% = 12.5%, one enrollment for every 8 leads.
  2. Leads needed: 20 ÷ 12.5% = 160 leads.
  3. Media budget: 160 × $40 = $6,400 for the month.
  4. Cost per sale: $6,400 ÷ 20 = $320.
  5. First-year commission: 20 × $544 = $10,880, leaving $4,480 after marketing.
  6. Break-even close rate: about 14.7%; most you could pay per lead: about $68.

Now change only the mix of new and switching clients. If all 20 were first-time Medicare Advantage enrollments, the same $6,400 would earn up to $14,500 and the break-even close rate would fall to about 11%. If all 20 were switches, the ceiling drops to $7,260 and the break-even close rate rises to about 22%. Same leads, same spend: who the leads are decides whether the month pays. For how to plan the season itself, see ourMedicare AEP marketing strategies, and for the program we run for Medicare agents, Medicare marketing for agents.

Which commission number to enter

Enter what one sale actually pays you in its first year, from your own contract or commission statements. How to get to that number depends on the line.

Medicare Advantage

CMS sets the maximum a plan may pay an independent agent per enrollment, and publishes it each year. For plan year 2027, the figures in CMS's June 1, 2026 memo,Contract Year 2027 Agent and Broker Compensation Rates, Referral/Finder's Fees, Submissions, and Training and Testing Requirements (copy of the memo), are:

RegionInitial yearRenewal years
National$725$363
Connecticut, Pennsylvania, DC$816$408
California, New Jersey$902$451
Puerto Rico, US Virgin Islands$495$248

Which column applies depends on the client. A first enrollment in Medicare Advantage is paid at the initial rate. A client who leaves one MA or MA-PD plan for another has made a "like plan type" change, and the federal rule pays that enrollment at the renewal rate (42 CFR 422.2274(a) and (d)(3)). CMS's Agent Broker Compensation page says the same in plain terms and links a data file with what each plan actually pays. That is why the calculator asks what share of your sales are switches. The figures are ceilings, not guaranteed pay: a carrier may pay less, and your contract governs.

Final expense, life, annuities and Medicare Supplement

In these lines commission is a percentage of premium set by your contract, so first-year commission is the average annual premium times your first-year rate. The "Work it out from premium" helper does that multiplication. If your contract pays an advance, part of it can be charged back when a policy lapses early, so enter the commission you expect to keep rather than the advance. Our breakdown offinal expense commission levelsshows how those schedules are built.

Property and casualty

Use your new-business commission for the first year. In P&C, commission comes again at each renewal, so a client's value builds well past year one, and a P&C channel can fail the first-year test and still be worth running. The main result leaves renewals out on purpose; open "Value past year one" under the inputs to add your renewal commission and retention (seewhat a sale is worth past year one). Theinsurance agency marketing budget guidewalks through the per-client math behind it.

Which number to fix first

Under the results, the calculator re-runs your plan three ways: contact rate 10 points higher, close rate 5 points higher, and leads 10% cheaper. Read those three lines before you buy more leads. Each lever has a different owner:

  • Contact rate is follow-up. How fast you call, how many attempts you make and when. It changes without changing vendor; ourinsurance lead follow-up cadence covers it.
  • Close rate is selling. Script, needs analysis, product fit and how warm the lead was when you reached it.
  • Cost per lead is the channel. If your vendor charges more than the "most you can pay per lead" line, more volume only loses money faster. Change the source, or build one you own: our insurance lead generation programis managed against cost per sale, and ourGoogle Ads management for insurance agents runs paid search the same way.

For a closer look at why a cheap lead can still cost more per sale, seelead price against true cost per sale.

Compare two lead sources side by side

Most lead decisions are a choice between two sources: shared or exclusive leads, aged or fresh, one vendor or another, bought leads or your own ads. Open "Compare a second lead source" under the inputs, enter source B's lead price, contact rate, close rate and any fixed cost of its own, and the calculator runs both for the same policies and the same commission. Cost per lead alone can't tell you which source to fund; cost per sale can.

Two extra numbers come out of the comparison. The matching lead price is the most source B can charge per lead before it costs more per sale than source A: (A's total monthly cost − B's fixed cost) ÷ B's leads needed. The matching close rate is the close rate B needs at its own lead price to cost the same per sale as A: (policies × B's cost per lead) ÷ (B's contact rate × (A's total monthly cost − B's fixed cost)). Bring both to the next call with a vendor: they turn "our leads close better" into a number the vendor has to beat.

Here is the worked example above (source A) against a lead that costs twice as much and is reached far more often, 80% of the time against 50% (source B). The B figures are placeholders like A's, not market averages; the "Load the worked example" button fills in both.

20 enrollments at $544Source ASource B
Cost per lead$40$80
Contact rate × close rate50% × 25% = 12.5%80% × 25% = 20%
Leads needed160100
Monthly cost$6,400$8,000
Cost per sale$320$400
Left after marketing$4,480$2,880

Source B needs 60 fewer leads and still costs $80 more per sale, because its price rose faster than its conversion. It would match source A at a lead price of about $64, or at $80 a lead with a close rate of about 31.3%. Push B's close rate to 35% and the answer flips: 72 leads, $5,760 for the month and $288 per sale, $32 under source A. That is why a split test has to measure contact and close rate per source; the price on the invoice never settles it. Our breakdowns ofexclusive vs shared final expense leadsand exclusive vs shared auto leads cover what changes those rates in each line.

Score your lead vendors from last month's results

The planner works forward from the rates you expect. Thelead vendor scorecard under it works back from what already happened. For each source, enter four counts from the same period: what you spent, the leads that came in, the leads you actually spoke to, and the policies sold. Spend has to include everything that source cost, so a vendor's platform fee or a dialer bought only for it goes in with the leads. "Leads you spoke to" is optional: without it the scorecard still gives cost per sale, but it can't tell you why one source costs more than another.

ResultFormula
Cost per leadspent ÷ leads
Contact rateleads you spoke to ÷ leads
Close ratepolicies sold ÷ leads you spoke to
Cost per salespent ÷ policies sold
One sale more / fewerspent ÷ (policies + 1), and spent ÷ (policies − 1)
Break-even lead pricefirst-year commission × policies sold ÷ leads
Lead price to match the best sourcebest cost per sale × policies sold ÷ leads
Cost per sale at the best source's contact ratecost per lead ÷ (best contact rate × own close rate); the same with the close rates swapped

Here are three vendors from one month. The counts are placeholders chosen to keep the arithmetic easy to follow, not market figures; the commission is the $544 CMS-based blend from the worked example above. "Load the worked example" on the scorecard fills them in.

One monthVendor 1Vendor 2Vendor 3
Spent$1,200$2,000$600
Leads / spoken to / sold120 / 60 / 650 / 40 / 8200 / 40 / 2
Cost per lead$10$40$3
Contact rate × close rate50% × 10%80% × 20%20% × 5%
Cost per sale$200$250$300
One sale more / fewer$171 / $240$222 / $286$200 / $600
Left after marketing$2,064$2,352$488
Break-even lead price$27.20$87.04$5.44

Three things come out of it that a cost-per-lead comparison hides:

  • The cheapest lead wasn't the cheapest sale. Vendor 3's leads cost $3 each, the lowest of the three, and its sales cost $300 each, the highest. At Vendor 1's contact rate (50%) the same leads would have cost about $120 per sale; at Vendor 1's close rate (10%), about $150. Reach is the bigger gap, so the first questions for that source are how old its leads are when they arrive and how fast they get called. Our lead follow-up cadencecovers the calling side.
  • The lowest cost per sale wasn't the most money. Vendor 1 had the lowest cost per sale, $200. Vendor 2 cost $250 per sale but sold 8 policies to Vendor 1's 6, so it left $2,352 after marketing against $2,064. Once a source pays for itself, the next question is how much more of it you can buy at the same rates.
  • A source that converts better can still be overpriced. Vendor 2 reached and closed more of its leads than Vendor 1 (80% and 20% against 50% and 10%), so its gap is the price: it would match Vendor 1's cost per sale at about $32 a lead, against the $40 paid. That is the number to bring to the renewal call.

Read the "one sale more / fewer" row before acting on any of it. Vendor 3's 2 sales put its cost per sale at $300; one sale more would have made it $200, one fewer $600. Small counts swing that far, so a month of results is a starting point, not a verdict. When a source's rates hold steady, "Plan next month with these rates" copies its cost per lead, contact rate and close rate into the planner above. If no bought source pays, the alternative is one you own: ourlead generation program for insurance agents is managed against cost per sale.

What a sale is worth past year one

First-year commission is the right test for whether a month's marketing pays for itself. It understates what a sale is worth wherever your contract pays renewal commission, as Medicare Advantage and property and casualty do. Open "Value past year one" under the inputs and enter three numbers of your own: the commission a policy pays in each renewal year, the share of policies still in force at each renewal, and how many years to count.

ResultFormula
Share still in force in year yry−1, where r is the share kept at each renewal
Commission per sale in year yrenewal commission × ry−1 (year 1 = first-year commission)
Commission per sale over N yearsfirst-year commission + renewal commission × (r + r² + … + rN−1)
Payback yearthe first year in which the running total passes cost per sale
Break-even close rate and most per lead over N yearsthe formulas above, with commission per sale over N years in place of first-year commission

Here is the worked example again with renewals added. The renewal figure is CMS's national renewal-year maximum for plan year 2027, $363, which a plan may pay for each year after the first that the member stays in the same plan or a like plan (42 CFR 422.2274); the 80% kept at each renewal and the 3-year window are placeholders, not a retention benchmark. The "Load the worked example" button fills them in.

YearStill in forceCommission per saleRunning total
Year 1100%$544$544
Year 280%$290$834
Year 364%$232$1,067

Cost per sale doesn't change: it is still $320, because the leads and the spend are the same month's. What changes is the ceiling. On first-year commission alone the most this agent could pay per lead is about $68; counting 3 years it is about $133, and the break-even close rate falls from about 14.7% to about 7.5%.

Use the longer view to decide what a source may cost, not to pay for this month. Renewal money arrives a year or more after the leads are paid for, only on policies that stay, and part of it pays for servicing them. A channel that only pays back in year three needs the cash to carry it that long. For keeping more of the book once it is written, see ourclient retention service.

Where agency fees and software go

Anything you pay each month regardless of lead volume belongs in the fixed-cost box: an agency retainer, a CRM, a dialer, software. A fixed fee is spread over the policies you write, so it weighs more at low volume. The Foundation tier at $2,500 a month adds $125 to the cost of each sale at 20 policies a month and $50 at 50.

Our own managed programs are published: Foundation $2,500, Growth $3,500 and Full-Funnel $5,500 a month, with ad spend billed at cost on top (seeinsurance marketing pricing). The tier buttons under the fixed-cost box drop each figure in, so you can see the cost per sale a retainer has to beat before you talk to anyone, us included. To set the overall ceiling as a share of revenue first, start withhow to set an insurance agency marketing budget.

What the calculator leaves out

  • Renewals, unless you add them. The main result uses first-year commission only. The optional "Value past year one" panel assumes the same renewal commission and the same retention every year, and doesn't discount money that arrives in later years.
  • The cost of keeping the book. Renewal commission also pays for servicing the policy, so the multi-year figures overstate what's left over.
  • Chargebacks, overrides and bonuses. Enter the first-year amount you expect to keep.
  • A mix of channels in one month. The comparison treats source B as an alternative to source A for the whole month, not a split of the volume between them.
  • Timing. It treats the month's spend and the month's commission as one period, although commission can arrive later.
  • Small samples. With a few dozen leads, one sale more or less moves the close rate a lot. Use several months of data where you have it.

Leads are rounded up to whole leads, and every money figure after that uses the rounded count. The break-even close rate and the most you can pay per lead are not rounded, which is why the calculator marks them "about".

Cite or link this calculator

You're welcome to link to this calculator or its lead vendor scorecard, quote its formulas, or share a screenshot or printout of your results. The "Copy link to these results" button gives a link that opens with your inputs filled in. Suggested citation:

Insurance Marketing Co, "Insurance Agency Marketing Budget & Cost-per-Sale Calculator", https://www.insurancemarketingco.com/tools/insurance-marketing-budget-calculator (updated November 18, 2026).

The Medicare Advantage figures are updated when CMS publishes the next plan year's compensation memo. Spotted a figure that has changed?Tell us and we'll correct it.

Frequently asked questions

How do you calculate cost per sale for insurance leads?

Divide what you spent in the month by the policies you wrote. For one lead source with no fixed costs that is the same as cost per lead ÷ (contact rate × close rate): a $40 lead at a 50% contact rate and a 25% close rate costs $320 per sale. Add fixed monthly costs, divided by policies, on top.

How many leads do I need to make one sale?

One divided by your sales per lead, where sales per lead is contact rate × close rate. At a 50% contact rate and a 20% close rate, sales per lead is 10%, so you need 10 leads per sale and 200 leads for 20 sales.

What is a break-even close rate?

The close rate at which first-year commission exactly covers the month's marketing cost. It equals (policies × cost per lead) ÷ (contact rate × (first-year commission − fixed cost)). If your real close rate sits below it, the channel loses money on first-year commission.

How much can I afford to pay per lead?

With no fixed costs, the most you can pay and still break even is commission per policy × contact rate × close rate. A $500 commission at a 50% contact rate and a 20% close rate supports up to $50 per lead. Fixed costs lower that ceiling; the calculator shows it for your numbers.

Are exclusive leads worth paying more for than shared leads?

Only if they are reached and closed often enough to cover the price. Compare cost per sale, not cost per lead: cost per lead ÷ (contact rate × close rate). A $40 lead at 50% contact and 25% close costs $320 per sale; an $80 lead at 80% and 25% costs $400, so the cheaper lead wins there. Raise the pricier lead's close rate enough and the answer flips. The calculator's comparison runs both sources with your own rates and shows the lead price and close rate at which they cost the same.

How do you compare insurance lead vendors?

On what each one produced, not on its price per lead. For the same period, divide each source's spend by the policies it sold to get cost per sale. Then split the gap: contact rate (leads you spoke to ÷ leads) shows reach, close rate (policies ÷ leads you spoke to) shows selling. The lead price at which a source would match your best one is the best cost per sale × its sales per lead. The lead vendor scorecard on this page does all three for up to three sources.

What commission should I enter for Medicare Advantage?

What your carrier actually pays. CMS caps it: for plan year 2027 the national maximum is $725 for an initial enrollment and $363 for a renewal, and a switch from one MA plan to another is paid at the renewal rate. Carriers may pay less, so check your contract or CMS's compensation data.

Does the calculator include renewals or chargebacks?

Renewals, optionally; chargebacks, no. The main result judges each month on first-year commission, the money that has to pay back the marketing first. The optional "Value past year one" panel adds your own renewal commission and retention for up to 10 years and shows the payback year and the most you can pay per lead over that period. Chargebacks on advanced commission aren't modelled: enter the first-year commission you expect to keep.

How do you work out the lifetime value of an insurance client?

Add the first-year commission to each renewal year's commission, scaled by the share of policies still in force: first-year commission + renewal commission × (r + r² + … ), where r is the share kept at each renewal. Stop at the number of years you are willing to wait for. Use your own commission schedule and your book's retention, not an industry figure.

Should an agency retainer go into the fixed cost?

Yes. Put any monthly fee that doesn't change with lead volume there: agency retainer, CRM, dialer, software. Ad spend goes into cost per lead instead. Our own programs are published at $2,500, $3,500 and $5,500 a month on the pricing page, with ad spend billed at cost.

Get a second opinion on your cost per sale.

Send us your numbers. In a free 15-minute teardown we go through your funnel and show where the cost per sale is leaking.

  • Site speed & conversion
  • Local + AI-search visibility
  • Ad efficiency
  • Your cost per lead vs ours
Book your 15-min teardownCall